Showing posts with label music for worship. Show all posts
Showing posts with label music for worship. Show all posts

Thursday, February 23, 2017

Too Much Bono in the Church? –– Part One

About ten years ago, I wrote an article called “Everything I Know about Worship Leading I Learned from an Irish Rock Star,” in which I reflected on Bono as the model for modern-day worship leaders. View all notes Because of my background in large Evangelical churches (Mars Hill Bible Church in Grand Rapids, Michigan, and Willow Creek Community Church in Chicago, Illinois), I lauded his ability to harness the energy of a stadium upward, affirmed his understand of the nature of praise, and was inspired by his relentless call to action on behalf of the poor. These were three characteristics of the kind of community we were trying to become, and U2 offered the ultimate example of worship in this kind of church.
But after seeing U2 last summer in Chicago, I no longer agree with what I wrote. . .
As I marveled at Bono’s ability to create such an epic worship experience, it occurred to me that this anthemic, euphoric, and cathartic euphoria is the perfect model for a traveling rock show but may be a potentially unhelpful model for weekly worship. And yet so many worship leaders––myself included––have been trying to emulate this mountaintop experience every Sunday morning for years, asking, “Did people lift their hands in the air? Did they sing loudly? Did they have a deeply authentic emotional experience?” These questions, learned from traveling rock stars, have come to define much of the current Christian worship culture.
Disney World is a wonderful place to visit but would be a strange place to live. An extravagant twelve-course meal is great for an anniversary celebration, but impossible to replicate every night. In the same way, I am becoming convinced that a rock concert worship event is wonderful in small doses but dangerous when it becomes normative.
Mountaintop experiences are not the entirety of the Christian life. And if our worship experience communicates that this is what everyone should be feeling all the time, we do a huge disservice to people who are currently in the valley or will be in the valley––which is everyone. There is a reason the Psalms include celebration, lament, anger, joy, dancing, and doubt. In fact, while over 30 percent of the Psalms are lament, looking at the top 100 contemporary (or “modern”) worship songs, you see that almost none are lament. As a result, our faith can get lopsided, and we do not always know how to engage the pain and heartbreak of life if we have only chosen the top songs or failed to use a range of Psalms.
Thankfully God does not just live on the mountaintop. . .  God does not always fix the issue but does something infinitely more profound: God weeps with us, inviting us to join the work of healing.
But to become aware of this, we cannot always be shouting from the triumphant peak. And a gracious, holistic church will offer its community wise practices, clear teaching, and safe spaces to learn how to embrace God in every emotional space from the summit to the valley.

Aaron Niequist is a worship leader, songwriter, and pastor. Currently, he curates a discipleship-focused, formational, ecumenical, practice-based community called “The Practice” at Willow Creek Community Church in South Barrington, Illinois.

Aaron Niequist, “Too Much Bono in the Church?” Liturgy 32, no. 1 (2017): 42-45.


Friday, July 29, 2016

Liturgy: This is Our Song

Introduction
David Bjorlin
“When in our music God is glorified,
and adoration leaves no room for pride,
it is as though the whole creation cried:
Alleluia!”
-Fred Pratt Green
     Since the current iteration of Liturgy began in 1980, the landscape of church music has continued its rapid evolution. Contemporary praise and worship music birthed in the late 1960s to early 1970s grew into the giant Contemporary Christian music (CCM) industries of Maranatha!, Hosanna!, Integrity, Hillsong, and Bethel Music (to name but a few) that have come to dominate the musical expressions of many evangelical and charismatic congregations. Roman Catholic congregational song found its footing in the second generation after the reforms of the Second Vatican Council with the creation of thousands of new songs, prayers, and liturgical settings to assist in the “full, conscious, and active participation” of the laity through song. The “hymn explosion” that had begun around 1970 spread beyond its source in England as hymn writers around the world wrote texts and tunes that grappled with a Christian response to contemporary topics of social justice, world peace, and environmental stewardship. Finally, the indigenous songs of the global South and East have enriched and expanded the musical palate of the global church.
Throughout this time of rapid change and expansion, Liturgy has been at the forefront of exploring the history, theology, and praxis of church music for its stated purpose of liturgical renewal, formation, and unity for the life of the world. As one can see from even a cursory glance at the journal’s musical bibliography (included in this issue), many of the most widely respected scholars and practitioners of church music have written over 100 articles on the church’s song, with six issues devoted to the task. While topics and opinions vary widely among contributors, each writes to promote and strengthen the church’s musical offering of prayer and praise to the triune God.
What you hold in your (digital!) hands is a first for Liturgy. The purpose of this issue is not to cover new ground, but to look back over the thirty-six years and unearth some of the buried treasures on church music from the journal’s archives. This virtual issue makes no claims to be a “best of”; such claims are almost always misguided and subjective. Rather, the articles were chosen based on two criteria: 1) articles that highlight the breadth of work done on church music by a wide-range of voices; and 2) articles that are of continued practical use to the church musicians, worship leaders, and pastors who plan music for worship. Because of this inherent limitation, a bibliography is also included that documents all of the articles in Liturgy that have been written on the topic of church music to assist in further exploration.
May you find in these pages new (and old!) thoughts, innovations, and resources on church music that can be used to enrich the song of your local church, so we may join all of creation in glorifying God with a deeper and truer “Alleluia!”




Friday, February 19, 2016

Thoughts on Music, Revelation, and Liturgy: Part Two

How does music in worship offer revelation about God? Michael Joncas sorts out the relationship between kinds of music and their effect on worshippers, beginning with the scriptural references to music in the assembly. He refers here to two kinds of revelation: general (especially through reasoning) and special (given through the Holy Spirit).
There is biblical evidence for the use of music to induce states of altered consciousness (namely, the prophetic frenzy reported in 1 Samuel 10:5b–6, 10–11). Perhaps the experience of glossolalia both in biblical times and among charismatic Christians can be seen as an example of special revelation (though the latter does not have the authoritative status of the former). . . . 
 [I]n many cases sung biblical texts are more memorable than those silently read or simply pronounced. “This is likely due to activating and linking different areas of the brain when visual codes are interpreted as verbal information, when that verbal information is yoked to the breath control and muscular activity involved in speaking, and when spoken verbal information is yoked in turn to recognition and interpretation of pitches, volumes, rhythms and timbres.” (Oliver Sacks, Musicophilia [NY: Vintage, 2008)]. They seem to carry a deeper emotional impact. . . 
Joncas shows that music sung in worship echoes the proclamation, teaching, communion, service, and witness that finds expression in Christian worship as a whole.
. . . “Evangelical” music is the counterpart of the church’s kerygma (proclamation). Just as Jesus proclaimed the proximate coming of the reign of God and called for a response of metanoia (transformation of values) to this good news, the church proclaims that the good news of the reign of God is embodied in Jesus, with acceptance of his way of life and joining his community as the appropriate response (e.g., “He is Lord, He is Lord, He is risen from the dead and he is Lord”). Thus the proper venue. . . is any situation in which non-Christians may be open to the Christian message (radio, television, films, videos, coffeehouses, concerts, etc.). . .  
 Catechetical music is the counterpart of the church’s didache (teaching). Having heard and converted to the kerygma, Christians still have to think through what their beliefs and appropriate behavior might be in the light of faith and in the context of the culture and history in which they find themselves (e.g., “Jesus loves me, this I know. . . ”). Thus, the proper venue. . . might be explicitly educational occasions 
 Fellowship music is the counterpart of the church’s koinonia (communion). Belief in the kerygma and conversion to the gospel way of life lived out in a particular time and place draws Christians together under the impetus of the Holy Spirit (e.g., “They’ll know we are Christians by our love”). The proper venue. . . might be any situation in which Christians revel in each other’s presence (common meals, hymn sings, skits, etc.). 
 Healing music is the counterpart of the church’s diakonia (service). Thinking through the implications of the good news leads Christians to acts of charity toward their own members and the wider community (e.g., “Be Not Afraid”). The proper venue. . . would be situations engaging the brokenness of the world (hospital, hospice, nursing home, retreat centers, etc.). 
 Confrontation music is the counterpart of the church’s martyria (witness). Thinking through the implications of the good news leads Christians to work for justice and singing witness songs. . . (e.g., “We Shall Overcome”).
This way of thinking about the power and work of music may cause worship planners, leaders, and musicians to look kindly on including a host of “styles” of music in a congregation’s repertoire of songs. 

Jan Michael Joncas, perhaps best known for his composition “On Eagles’ Wings,” is an associate professor in theology at the University of St. Thomas in St. Paul, Minnesota.

Jan Michael Joncas, “’Ring Out, Ye Crystal Spheres?’: Thoughts on Music Revelation, and Liturgy,” Liturgy 31, no. 1 (2016), 34-41.



Friday, October 16, 2015

Musical Choices for Worship

Having described some findings about the brain’s receipt of music in his essay in Liturgy 30, no. 4, Tony Alonso continues his remarks on the relationship between music and worship.

In a book of reflections on the relationship between music and theology, Don Saliers writes about music as a living practice that is deeply bodily and intimately bound to our emotional lives. Reflecting on the theological significance of the ways in which music has potential to both shape and express our image of God, Saliers notes that controversies about music in Christian history emerge “precisely because music—played, sung, and heard—remains both emotionally powerful and yet mysteriously ephemeral, always passing away in linear time, yet always fusing past, future and present.” . . . It holds great potential for deepening contemporary conversations over musical styles in worship and, in particular, for helping to explain why such conversations can be so deeply felt and emotionally charged. 
 . . . Acknowledging the very human way in which musical tastes develop and the vulnerable emotional associations music has the ability to encode. . . challenges an uncritical assumption that the Spirit sings only through a particular genre or musical expression and instead opens us to the unexpected and perhaps even uncomfortable ways in which people hear God’s voice in a wide variety of modes.

Not content merely to call for new music, Alonso offers several conclusions about worship music. Here we have room to relate only a few.
[A]ttentiveness to the development of musical taste from the first music to which we are exposed as infants to its strong solidification in our teenage years should make us suspicious of whether marketing musical repertoire toward a specific demographic is salutary or even possible. . . . The cellist in the high school orchestra who enjoys listening to popular music with her friends and the mariachi music of her Mexican heritage surely has the potential to connect to the sacred through more than one musical genre. 
 . . . Levitin’s examination of the development of musical taste should cause us to reject the use of the terms traditional and contemporary to describe styles of music in worship. . . This unhelpful binary is not only musically inaccurate; it also ignores multivalent musical schemas, which do not fit neatly into such categories. 
 . . . [M]uch of contemporary praise and worship music used in Christian worship sounds less like the Top 40 and more like a popular musical schema from ten or twenty years in the past. Regardless of intention and without casting any judgment on the aesthetic quality of such music, it is possible that the adults who often hold the power in worship settings may be unknowingly masking a desire for music that reflects the comfortable musical schemas of their own teenage years. If musical evangelization in worship is a priority (an open question in itself), this work invites a deeper conversation about how such music might sound quite different than what is currently in the Christian mainstream. . . 
 The lack of rap, reggae, country, and hip-hop music played and sung in most communities who use music to evangelize testifies to the often unspoken limits. . . often as narrowly drawn as those who advocate for the exclusive use of Gregorian chant or the hymns of Charles Wesley. 
Urging greater thought be given to the choices for music used in worship, Alonso shows that musical tastes cannot be easily categorized by age group or ethnicity. The music most appropriate not only for the worship of the faithful – but for people new to worship, as well – is the music most faithful to the church’s witness. See his full essay to deepen your understanding of his important perspective.


Tony Alonso is a composer of liturgical music and a PhD student in the Graduate Division of Religion at Emory University in Atlanta, Georgia.

Tony Alonso, “A Not-So-Universal Language: What Neuroscience Can Teach Us about Music Styles in Worship,” Liturgy 30, no. 4 (2015), 53-60.


Friday, July 17, 2015

Music and Meaning for the “Spiritual But Not Religious”

E. Byron Anderson’s recent essay in Liturgy begins by asking whether music has inherent spiritual qualities. If worship planners want to make an effort to reach out to the self-defined  “Spiritual But Not Religious” folks in our communities, what considerations need to be made about musical choices? Using research from a number of music scholars, Anderson answers that music in not inherently “spiritual” but is perceived as such by what the listener brings to it. The spirituality of music arises from an encounter between sound and hearer.

Asking what worship leaders and musicians might learn, then, about music for worshipping assemblies, Anderson addresses the distinction made by SBNRs between what is “religious” and what is “spiritual.”

Historically, the terms religious and sacred, as well as religious and spiritual, were synonymous in discussions of music, but today they are often defined in oppositional terms. The religious is understood as public, communal, institutional, exterior, intellectual, and objective. . . . grounded in and intentional about its connection to traditions, disciplines, and communities of practice, and. . .  thought to be overly concerned with correct beliefs. Religion is a particular way of life, marked by particular patterns, practices, communities, and commitments. Its patterns, practices, and commitments “exist before the individual” and are “bigger than the individual.” (Douglas Jacobsen and Rhonda Hustedt Jacobsen, “Talking about Religion,” in  The American University in a Postsecular Age [New York: Oxford University Press, 2008], 223)  
. . . On these terms, denominational hymnals might serve as representatives of religious music. Although hymnals were initially purchased and used individually, often for personal devotion, they are found today primarily in communal spaces (churches), often with some signifier of denominational identity on their covers. They are developed not by local communities or by individuals but by denominational committees. They express in content and organization the theological perspectives and beliefs of the denomination and they are intended to serve the liturgies and rites of that denomination. They represent the theological and musical development of a tradition. Often implied in the rejection of such religious music is the notion that the only valid interpretation of that music is the official denominational interpretation. We know, however, that interpretation of even the most familiar hymn text and tune will be a mixture of official, local, and personal meanings––developed over time in varying contexts and circumstances. Yet it is a hymnal’s very form that permits individuals to linger with a text (and tune), to study it, to reflect on or pray with it, and to make it. . . part of the community’s language of prayer, [shared] across generations.
 The spiritual, in contrast, is popularly described today as something that is private, genuine, interior, affective, and subjective. It is more focused on inner, even mystical, experiences than on the outward practices of a person’s life. . . . It may explore and widely borrow practices from various religious traditions, often without regard for the connections between those practices and the beliefs that gave them birth. Not only does it often disregard those connections, but also it is often intentional in its disconnection from traditions of practice and belief. The spiritual emphasizes personal effort in the search for self-actualization. Religion and tradition are seen as hindrances to, if not enemies of, genuine spirituality. Meaning is found only in the eye, or here the ear, of the beholder.
Technological changes in how music can be heard are altering much more than the sheer availability of music. Today individuals can amass a musical playlist based in personal taste. Gone is the need to rely on printed books of songs. The question for planners of music in worship has to do with whether it is still possible, in a time of such enhanced individual choice, to really listen to the music as one would do with hymns printed in a hymn book. “Religious” music is assembled by a denomination; “spiritual” music, by the individual. Between these two assemblages of music lies a chasm that has bearing on theological understanding and communal cohesion.

[S]ome church musicians have expressed [concern] about the transition from printed hymnals—and their diminishing place in many North American Protestant congregations—to projected texts. The projected text, which, unlike a hymnal, is characterized by impermanence, participates in or contributes to the “present experience” of music/text. Once the image of the text is gone, so is the text; we cannot linger with it, study it, or even share it as we might with a printed page. . .
Our assemblies may be changed by how worship planners choose and present music. These decisions may in turn, be altering how worshippers understand music’s role in our lives and in our ways of living. 


E. Byron Anderson is Styberg Professor of Worship and director of the Nellie B. Ebersole Program in Music Ministry at Garrett-Evangelical Theological Seminary. He served as president of The Liturgical Conference from 2004 to 2015. His published works include Worship and Christian Identity: Practicing Ourselves (Pueblo Books, 2003).

E. Byron Anderson, “Music and Meaning for the ‘Spiritual But Not Religious,” Liturgy 30, no. 3 (2015): 14-22.